A rant: Cliven Bundy still owes the taxpayers a million bucks

Grand Canyon west
Horses on BLM land in Arizona.

Freed Sagebrush rebel Cliven Bundy spoke to the media two days after his release from jail about his options.

Bundy said he has two – to “forgive these people or … hold them accountable.”

There is a third option. He could pay his grazing leases. Bundy owes the government more than $1 million in grazing fees that go back to the 1990s. His refusal to pay is where his legal trouble started.

Bundy did not walk from jail because the thrust of his legal argument – that the federal government has no right to own land – holds water. He walked because prosecutors screwed up. His ideas about federal land ownership may be goofy, but he deserved a fair trial. Now that he got one, maybe he should stop talking so much.

For those who slept through history class, the feds own land because they paid for it, in blood and treasure, as conservationist Rich Rudow likes to say. United States taxpayers acquired western lands through the Louisiana Purchase, through treaties with Britain, Spain, Mexico and Indian tribes. The government also sent federal troops to take or secure this land, paying for it with the lives of soldiers. A law professor might add that the Supreme Court has upheld the system for a couple of centuries and that when territories become states, they give all their unclaimed land to the United States.

For decades, the U.S. government pretty much gave away its land to homesteaders. Now that the giveaway is over, some people want to rewrite the rules.

When Utah passed legislation to lay claim to federal lands within its borders, the feds pretty much ignored it. Even with Ryan Zinke as Secretary of Interior, Utah may be getting some monuments reduced, but it’s not getting that land. The land goes back to the same underfunded federal agencies that had them before.

Some might say that Utah is testing the legal system and challenging the status quo. Some might say there is no harm in that. But the state has lost the Outdoor Retailer show as a result of its positions on public lands. That will cost the state millions.

When Bundy speaks, however, people show up with guns. One person is dead. Maybe it’s time to try something new. Maybe it’s time for him to pay his grazing fees.

3 thoughts on “A rant: Cliven Bundy still owes the taxpayers a million bucks

  1. From A Canadian point of view
    Once land has been sold to a countries citizens, you can’t police it or get it back without expropriating it at a high tax pay cost. I have a hard time understanding this concept of no Crown Land. That is what Canadian’s call land owned by province, territory or federal government.
    How do you protect rivers, streams, plan new towns put up highways or take care of water aquifers of sensitive ecology and environment areas, if everyone owns every piece of land? The Crown must own land and set it aside. We don’t know the important symbiotic relationship every ecological part of a place, until it is gone and its animals and plant extinct.
    It is like saving for a rainy day.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s